Technical Analysis vs Fundamental Analysis: Differences and What Research Shows
What each approach studies, the ratios and chart tools it uses, a worked example of the main fundamental ratios, and what the main academic tests found on both sides, with data going back to 1897, quoted from each paper's summary or, for Piotroski, from Chicago Booth Review.

On this page
Technical analysis studies price and volume to decide when to buy or sell; fundamental analysis studies a company's accounts, its industry and the economy to decide what an asset is worth and whether to own it. They answer different questions and can be combined: in a survey of 692 fund managers in five countries, the vast majority relied on technical analysis, which was the most important form of analysis at a horizon of weeks and, up to that horizon, more important than fundamental analysis. The research on whether either one earns money after costs is more mixed than its advocates say, and this page sums up what the main papers actually found.
S&P 500 ETF with its 200-day moving average

- Price, daily candles (hollow up, filled down)
- SMA(200) of the close (solid line)
Technical analysis vs fundamental analysis at a glance
| Technical analysis | Fundamental analysis | |
|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | When to buy or sell | What to buy, and what it is worth |
| Data | Price and volume | Financial statements, the industry, the economy |
| Usual horizon | Days to months | Months to years |
| Main tools | Charts, trends, moving averages, patterns | Earnings, valuation ratios, cash flow, management |
| Works on | Any traded market, including currencies and crypto | Assets with cash flows: stocks, bonds; partly currencies |
| Main criticism | Rules found on past data often fail afterwards | The market may take years to agree with your value |
What is technical analysis?
Technical analysis studies past prices and volume to judge the trend and the odds of the next move. It assumes that price already reflects what market participants know and expect, and that crowds repeat some behaviors. Its tools are trends, support and resistance, indicators such as the moving average on the chart above, and chart patterns such as the head and shoulders. It works the same on any market with a price history, from a stock to a currency pair or Bitcoin, and its roots go back to Dow theory at the end of the nineteenth century.
A close relative, which reads the bars themselves without indicators, is price action trading.
What is fundamental analysis?
Fundamental analysis estimates what an asset is worth from the cash it can produce, then compares that value with the price. For a stock, it looks at two kinds of factors:
- Qualitative: the business model, competitive position, management, industry trends and regulation.
- Quantitative: revenue, earnings, debt, cash flow and the ratios built from the financial statements.
It is often taught top down, from the economy to the industry to the company. Value investing is a common application: buying stocks whose price is well below the value the analyst estimates and waiting for the market to close the gap.
Fundamental analysis, top down

The main fundamental ratios
The SEC's investor glossary defines earnings per share as "A public company's net profit divided by the number of its common shares" (Investor.gov) and the P/E ratio as the current stock price divided by the current earnings per share, those earnings being "the earnings for the past 12 months" (Investor.gov). The table applies these and five other common ratios to a hypothetical company with $500 million of annual sales, $50 million of net profit, $400 million of shareholders' equity, 25 million shares at $40 and a dividend of $0.80 per share.
| Ratio | How it is calculated | Hypothetical company |
|---|---|---|
| Earnings per share (EPS) | Net profit / common shares | $50 million / 25 million = $2.00 |
| Price to earnings (P/E) | Share price / EPS | $40 / $2.00 = 20 |
| Return on equity (ROE) | Net profit / shareholders' equity | $50 million / $400 million = 12.5% |
| Price to sales (P/S) | Market value / annual sales | $1,000 million / $500 million = 2 |
| Price to book (P/B) | Market value / shareholders' equity | $1,000 million / $400 million = 2.5 |
| Dividend yield | Annual dividend per share / share price | $0.80 / $40 = 2% |
| Payout ratio | Dividend per share / EPS | $0.80 / $2.00 = 40% |
None of these numbers means much alone: a P/E of 20 can be high for a slow-growing company and low for a fast-growing one. Analysts compare each ratio with the company's own history and with its competitors. For debt, a common one is the interest coverage ratio, which shows how many times operating profit covers the interest bill.
What does the research say about each?
Both approaches have been tested for decades. The results below come from each paper or its summary, and for Piotroski from Chicago Booth Review's account; none of them proves that a rule will work in the future.
| Study | Market and period | What it found |
|---|---|---|
| Brock, Lakonishok and LeBaron (1992) | Dow Jones index, 1897 to 1986 | Moving average and trading range rules: "strong support for the technical strategies" |
| Sullivan, Timmermann and White (1998 discussion paper) | Brock et al.'s rules, expanded to nearly 8,000 variants; Dow Jones, 1987 to 1996 | Out of sample, "scant evidence" that the rules had economic value |
| Lo, Mamaysky and Wang (2000) | US stocks, 1962 to 1996 | Chart patterns detected automatically: "several technical indicators" may have "some practical value" |
| Park and Irwin (2007) | Review of 95 modern studies | 56 positive, 20 negative, 19 mixed; most suffer from data snooping and cost problems |
| Fama and French (1992) | US stocks | Size and book-to-market explain differences in average returns; beta does not |
| Piotroski (2000), F_SCORE | Cheap US stocks, 1976 to 1996 | Nine accounting signals raised the return of high book-to-market stocks by at least 7.5% a year |
Technical analysis. Brock, Lakonishok and LeBaron tested moving average and trading range break rules on the Dow Jones from 1897 to 1986 and found "strong support for the technical strategies" (Journal of Finance, 1992). Sullivan, Timmermann and White then corrected for data snooping, the risk of finding a rule that worked by luck among thousands tried. The rules still did well up to 1986, but on the ten following years they found "scant evidence that technical trading rules were of any economic value", and "the best performing trading rule is not even statistically significant at standard critical levels" (Sullivan, Timmermann and White). Lo, Mamaysky and Wang detected chart patterns automatically on US stocks from 1962 to 1996 and concluded that "several technical indicators do provide incremental information and may have some practical value" (NBER working paper 7613). Park and Irwin reviewed 95 modern studies: 56 found positive results, 20 negative and 19 mixed, but most were "subject to various problems in their testing procedures", such as data snooping, the ex post selection of trading rules and the estimation of risk and transaction costs (Journal of Economic Surveys, 2007).
What 95 modern studies of technical trading rules found

Fundamental analysis. Fama and French found that two easily measured variables, size and book-to-market equity, capture the cross-sectional variation in average stock returns, while the relation between market beta and average return is flat (Journal of Finance, 1992). Piotroski built a score from nine accounting signals and applied it to stocks with a high book-to-market ratio: the average return of such an investor "can be increased by at least 7.5 percent annually", and over 1976 to 1996 the highest-scoring firms had a one-year market-adjusted return of 13.4 percent against minus 9.6 percent for the lowest-scoring ones, outperforming them by 23 percent (Chicago Booth Review, on the paper published in the Journal of Accounting Research in 2000). Both results are tests on past data, open to the same data-snooping question as technical rules.
Who uses what. In Menkhoff's survey of 692 fund managers in five countries, the vast majority relied on technical analysis, and "At a forecasting horizon of weeks, technical analysis is the most important form of analysis" (Journal of Banking and Finance, 2010). More on that question in do professional traders use technical analysis. We measure chart patterns ourselves against random entries, on many markets, with the method described in our methodology.
How the two approaches differ in practice
One way to combine fundamental and technical analysis

- Value vs consensus: fundamental analysis looks for the value the market has not yet priced in; technical analysis accepts the price as the market's consensus and follows its changes.
- Picking vs timing: fundamentals help choose which stock to own; the chart helps choose when to enter and exit.
- Future vs past: fundamental analysts forecast future earnings; technical analysts study past prices and assume some behaviors repeat.
- Horizon: a fundamental thesis can take years to play out; a technical signal is usually judged over days to months. Swing and day trading, compared in day trader vs swing trader, rely mostly on charts.
- Asset coverage: a currency pair or Bitcoin has no earnings to analyze, so traders of those markets lean on charts and macroeconomic data.
Can you combine technical and fundamental analysis?
Yes. One combination screens stocks on fundamentals, keeps those with sound earnings and a reasonable valuation, then waits for the chart to confirm, for example a price back above its 200-day average or a breakout from a range. The opposite works too: a technical signal on a stock with weak finances is a reason for a smaller position or a closer stop. Each approach also affects the other: earnings reports move prices, and price moves change the valuation ratios.
We cannot show both on one stock here: this site's data holds prices, not financial statements. The chart at the top of the page shows the technical half on the S&P 500 ETF, with its 200-day average, and the ratios table the fundamental half on a hypothetical company. To read the broad trend before either, see market direction; for tested trading rules, see swing trading strategies for beginners; more ideas are in trading concepts. To learn chart reading in a structured way, our comparison of the best technical analysis courses includes a free option.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, technical or fundamental analysis?
Neither in general; they answer different questions. Fundamental analysis suits long-term investors choosing what to own, technical analysis suits traders choosing when to act. The academic evidence for each is mixed once data snooping and costs are accounted for.
What are the three components of fundamental analysis?
It is usually taught as economic analysis, industry analysis and company analysis, from the top down. The company analysis covers both qualitative factors, such as management, and quantitative ones, such as earnings and ratios.
What is an example of technical analysis vs fundamental analysis?
A fundamental analyst buys a stock because its P/E of 12 is below its competitors' while earnings grow. A technical analyst buys the same stock because its price closed above its 200-day moving average after a breakout. Some traders wait for both.
Can technical analysis be used for long-term investing?
Yes, on weekly or monthly charts, mainly to judge the trend and time entries. Long-term returns of stocks still depend on earnings, which charts do not measure.
Does fundamental analysis work for crypto and forex?
Only partly. A currency's value depends on interest rates, inflation and trade, which are fundamentals of a country rather than a company. Most crypto assets have no earnings or cash flows, so traders rely more on price and on-chain or adoption data.
Sources
- Brock, Lakonishok and LeBaron, Simple Technical Trading Rules and the Stochastic Properties of Stock Returns (Journal of Finance, 1992)
- Sullivan, Timmermann and White, Data-Snooping, Technical Trading Rule Performance, and the Bootstrap (LSE discussion paper 303)
- Lo, Mamaysky and Wang, Foundations of Technical Analysis (NBER working paper 7613, 2000)
- Park and Irwin, What Do We Know About the Profitability of Technical Analysis? (Journal of Economic Surveys, 2007)
- Fama and French, The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns (Journal of Finance, 1992)
- Chicago Booth Review, Separating winners from losers (on Piotroski's F_SCORE)
- Menkhoff, The use of technical analysis by fund managers: International evidence (Journal of Banking and Finance, 2010)
- SEC, Investor.gov glossary: Price-earnings (P/E) ratio
- Piotroski, Value Investing: The Use of Historical Financial Statement Information to Separate Winners from Losers (Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 38, 2000), EconPapers record
