Trading concepts

Is Trading a Zero-Sum Game? Futures, Options, Stocks and Forex

What zero-sum means in game theory, which markets fit the definition and which do not, a worked futures example, the long-run record of the S&P 500, and Sharpe's arithmetic of active management.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 7 min read
A futures contract is zero-sum; shares held for years are not: left, one futures contract over time: the long side's gains and the short side's losses are mirror images around a dashed zero line, so long plus short equals zero before costs. Right, shares held for years: two holders' values both rise above their dashed starting value, gaining together from company profits.
On this page
  1. Zero-sum and non-zero-sum games
  2. Is trading a zero-sum game? Market by market
  3. Futures and options: the closest thing to a pure zero-sum game
  4. The stock market is not zero-sum
  5. Beating the market is zero-sum: Sharpe's arithmetic
  6. What it means for your trading
  7. Frequently asked questions

A zero-sum game is a situation where one side's gain equals the other side's loss, so the total stays at zero. Trading is zero-sum in some places and not in others. Futures and options are zero-sum between buyers and sellers before costs, and negative-sum after them. The stock market as a whole is not zero-sum, because companies produce profits: the S&P 500 index rose from 93.00 to 7,743.98 between January 1970 and October 2026, before dividends. Beating the market, however, is zero-sum before costs, as William Sharpe showed.

A futures contract is zero-sum; shares held for years are not

A futures contract is zero-sum; shares held for years are not: left, one futures contract over time: the long side's gains and the short side's losses are mirror images around a dashed zero line, so long plus short equals zero before costs. Right, shares held for years: two holders' values both rise above their dashed starting value, gaining together from company profits.
Left
the buyer's and the seller's result on the same contract
Right
two holders of shares in growing companies
Schematic, not market data. Before costs: commissions put the futures pair below zero, and shares can also fall for long stretches.On a futures contract the buyer's gain is the seller's loss; holders of shares in profitable companies can all gain together.

Zero-sum and non-zero-sum games

The idea comes from game theory, formalized by John von Neumann and Oskar Morgenstern in Theory of Games and Economic Behavior (Princeton University Press, 1944), whose early chapters deal with zero-sum two-person games (publisher's page). In a zero-sum game the payoffs of all players add up to zero whatever happens: poker between friends, with no house cut, is one. In a non-zero-sum game the total can be positive (a trade that benefits both sides) or negative (a price war that hurts every competitor). The prisoner's dilemma is the classic non-zero-sum example: two suspects who both stay silent do better together than if both confess, yet each has a reason to confess.

Is trading a zero-sum game? Market by market

MarketZero-sum?Why
FuturesYes before costs, negative afterEvery long has a short; daily settlement moves cash from the losing side to the winning side
OptionsYes before costs, negative afterThe buyer's gain is the writer's loss, and the reverse
Stocks, the whole marketNo, positive-sum over long periodsCompanies earn profits and pay dividends; the index rose about 83 times from 1970 to 2026, price only
Stocks, beating the marketYes before costs, negative afterSharpe's arithmetic: the average active dollar earns the market return before costs
ForexClose to zero-sum for price movesOne currency rising against another is the other falling against it; interest rate differences and hedging needs add other motives
CFDs with a dealerZero-sum between client and dealer before costs, when the dealer keeps the other sideThe dealer is the counterparty to the client's trade

Futures and options: the closest thing to a pure zero-sum game

In futures, every contract has a buyer and a seller. The CFTC glossary defines open interest as the total number of futures contracts long or short in a delivery month or market, and describes mark to market as part of the daily cash flow system US futures exchanges use to maintain a minimum level of margin equity (see the CFTC glossary). Every day the losing side pays variation margin and the winning side receives it, so the money moves from one to the other without any being created.

The futures example: gains and losses before and after costs

The futures example: gains and losses before and after costs. Buyer, before costs: +$2,000; Seller, before costs: −$2,000; Buyer, after a $5 commission: +$1,995; Seller, after a $5 commission: −$2,005; Both traders together, after costs: −$10. Hypothetical example, computed from the assumptions in the text.
Hypothetical example, computed from the assumptions in the text.One contract at $50 per point, bought and sold at 6,000, settled at 6,040. Before costs the two results add up to zero; the commissions make the total negative.

The stock market is not zero-sum

A share is a claim on a company's profits. When the companies in an index earn more over time, all holders can gain together, with no one on the losing side. On our daily closes of the S&P 500, the index went from 93.00 on January 2, 1970 to 7,743.98 on October 28, 2026, about 83 times its starting level and about 8.1% a year over 56.8 years, not counting dividends. Of the 55 full calendar years from 1971 to 2025, 41 closed higher. That is not a zero-sum result.

With dividends reinvested the gain is larger. The chart below follows an S&P 500 ETF on dividend-adjusted prices: its monthly close went from 24.31 in February 1993 to 762.63 in September 2026, about 31 times. On the logarithmic panel, equal heights are equal percentage moves, which shows how steady the long rise was apart from the bear markets.

S&P 500 ETF with dividends reinvested, monthly, 1993 to 2026

S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, monthly candlesticks, February 1993 to September 2026, on a linear and a logarithmic scale. Top: linear scale, equal price changes take equal heights. Bottom: logarithmic scale, equal percentage changes take equal heights. Illustration of how the chart type is drawn, not a backtest.
  • Classic monthly candlesticks, hollow when the close is at or above the open, filled below
S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, monthly candlesticks, February 1993 to September 2026, on a linear and a logarithmic scale. Top: linear scale, equal price changes take equal heights. Bottom: logarithmic scale, equal percentage changes take equal heights. Illustration of how the chart type is drawn, not a backtest.

It is not a promise either: the same index lost 56.8% on a closing basis between October 9, 2007 and March 9, 2009 (see bullish vs bearish markets for every bear market since 1970).

Beating the market is zero-sum: Sharpe's arithmetic

In "The Arithmetic of Active Management" (Financial Analysts' Journal, January/February 1991), William F. Sharpe showed that if passive investors hold the market, active investors as a group must hold it too. So "before costs, the return on the average actively managed dollar will equal the return on the average passively managed dollar", and "after costs, the return on the average actively managed dollar will be less than the return on the average passively managed dollar" (full text on Sharpe's Stanford site). In his definitions, a passive investor always holds every security in the market in the same proportions as the market, and an active investor is anyone who does not.

Sharpe's arithmetic of active management

Sharpe's arithmetic of active management: a dashed line marks the market return. Passive dollars sit exactly on it. Active dollars before costs are spread above it, the winners, and below it, the losers, and their average sits on the line. After costs, the whole active group moves down by the costs and its average falls below the market return.
Schematic, not market data. Drawn from the reasoning of Sharpe's article, without any measured return.Before costs the active group earns the market on average; costs move the whole group below it.

Sharpe stresses that these assertions "depend only on the laws of addition, subtraction, multiplication and division". For a trader it means that every dollar of outperformance has, before costs, a matching dollar of underperformance somewhere else, and that costs push the group as a whole below the market.

What it means for your trading

  • Costs decide more in zero-sum games. In futures, options and short-term stock trading against the market, commissions, spreads and slippage come straight out of the total. Count them in every backtest; the trading math guide shows how they change expectancy.
  • Know who is on the other side. Some are hedgers who accept a loss on the contract to protect a business; others are traders with faster tools, as described in the high-frequency trading guide.
  • Holding period changes the game. A long-term holder of a stock index collects the positive-sum of company profits; a short-term trader mostly plays the relative game. The day trader vs swing trader comparison looks at the trade-offs.
  • A small edge needs safe sizing. In a game close to zero-sum the edge is thin, and the risk of ruin climbs fast when you risk too much per trade.

Other market concepts are in trading concepts.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

Is trading 100% gambling?

Not by definition. Holding assets that produce profits has been positive-sum over long periods: the S&P 500 rose about 83 times from 1970 to 2026, before dividends. Short term trading against other traders is close to zero-sum before costs and negative-sum after, so an edge is harder to find, though not impossible.

Is the stock market a zero-sum game?

Not as a whole: company profits let all holders gain together, and the S&P 500 rose about 83 times from 1970 to 2026, before dividends. Trying to beat the market is zero-sum before costs, because the average active dollar earns the market return.

Is forex a zero-sum game?

For price moves, close to it: one currency gaining against another is the other losing. Interest rate differences between currencies and participants who trade to hedge a business make the picture less simple.

Are options a zero-sum game?

Yes before costs: what the buyer gains the writer loses, and the reverse. After commissions and spreads, the total for buyers and writers together is negative.

What is a non-zero-sum game?

A situation where the total of all players' results can be positive or negative. A trade that benefits both sides is positive-sum; a price war that hurts every competitor is negative-sum.

Sources

  1. William F. Sharpe, The Arithmetic of Active Management, Financial Analysts' Journal, 1991
  2. John von Neumann and Oskar Morgenstern, Theory of Games and Economic Behavior (Princeton University Press)
  3. CFTC glossary
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

All trading concepts articles