Trading concepts

What Is a Good Stop Loss Percentage? Percent vs ATR Stops Tested

Fixed percentage stops against ATR stops under random entries on the S&P 500 ETF, Bitcoin and EUR/USD: how often each was hit within 20 sessions, how noisy that is, and how to calculate your own stop.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 9 min read
ATR(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, August 5, 2026 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.
On this page
  1. Percentage stops vs ATR stops: the test
  2. How noisy these numbers are
  3. How to calculate a stop loss
  4. Other ways to place a stop
  5. Frequently asked questions

There is no single good stop loss percentage, because the same percentage means a small move in one market and a large one in another. On our data, a stop 2% below a random entry was hit within 20 sessions 53.5% of the time on the S&P 500 ETF, 80.4% of the time on Bitcoin and 39.2% of the time on EUR/USD. A stop placed at twice the 14-day average true range (ATR) was hit 47.8%, 42.6% and 51.2% of the time: the ATR scales the distance to each market's normal moves. Pick the distance from the market's noise, then choose the position size so that a hit costs a fixed share of your account.

ATR(14) on the daily S&P 500 ETF

ATR(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, October 30, 2025 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.
  • Price, daily candles (hollow up, filled down)
  • ATR(14), Wilder average of the true range (solid line)
ATR(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, October 30, 2025 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.

Percentage stops vs ATR stops: the test

The rule we ran on daily bars: for every session with an ATR value, assume a long entry at the close and place a sell stop either a fixed percentage below the entry or a multiple of the ATR(14) of the entry day. The stop counts as hit if any low of the next 20 sessions reaches it. When a session opens below the stop, the exit is taken at that open, not at the stop. The entries ignore any signal, so the test measures how much room each stop leaves for ordinary moves, not whether a strategy makes money. ETF prices are dividend-adjusted.

  • S&P 500 ETF: 1,428 entries from January 25, 2021 to September 30, 2026, followed to October 28, 2026.
  • Bitcoin: 566 entries from March 22, 2025 to October 8, 2026, followed to October 28, 2026.
  • EUR/USD: 566 entries from April 2, 2021 to June 2, 2023, followed to June 30, 2023.

The three windows are not the same, so read each column on its own. Share of entries whose stop was hit within 20 sessions (for ATR stops, the median distance of the stop below the entry in brackets):

StopS&P 500 ETFBitcoinEUR/USD
2% below entry53.5%80.4%39.2%
5% below entry19.4%53.9%3.7%
8% below entry9.2%32.3%0 of 566
1 ATR below entry67.9% (median 1.1%)69.1% (median 2.9%)75.4% (median 0.8%)
2 ATR below entry47.8% (median 2.3%)42.6% (median 5.9%)51.2% (median 1.6%)
3 ATR below entry31.4% (median 3.4%)23.5% (median 8.8%)35.0% (median 2.3%)

A fixed percentage changes meaning from one market to the next. On these medians, 2% was about 1.8 ATR on the ETF, 0.7 ATR on Bitcoin and 2.6 ATR on EUR/USD, so the same 2% stop was hit 39.2% to 80.4% of the time depending on the market. The 2 ATR stop was hit 42.6% to 51.2% of the time across the three. An 8% stop was never reached on EUR/USD in 566 entries, while on Bitcoin it was hit about one time in three.

Share of random entries stopped within 20 sessions

Share of random entries stopped within 20 sessions. S&P 500 ETF, Jan 2021 to Sep 2026: Stop 2% below entry 53.5%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 47.8%; Bitcoin, Mar 2025 to Oct 2026: Stop 2% below entry 80.4%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 42.6%; EUR/USD, Apr 2021 to Jun 2023: Stop 2% below entry 39.2%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 51.2%. Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.
  • Stop 2% below entry
  • Stop 2 ATR below entry
Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.Long entry at every daily close, stop hit if a low of the next 20 sessions reaches it; ATR(14) of the entry day. The fixed 2% spreads from 39.2% to 80.4%, the 2 ATR stop stays between 42.6% and 51.2%.

How noisy these numbers are

The entries overlap: two entries a day apart share 19 of their 20 sessions. The ETF sample holds about 71 separate 20-session windows, Bitcoin and EUR/USD about 28 each, so differences of a few points between markets are not meaningful. The spread between years shows the noise: on the ETF, the 2% stop was hit 41.7% of the time in 2024 and 81.3% in 2022; the 2 ATR stop 39.6% in 2025 and 61.0% in 2022. The ATR is measured over the 14 sessions before the stop is set, so when volatility jumps, as in 2022, ATR stops are hit more often too. On Bitcoin the 2 ATR stop was hit 50.5% of the time on 2025 entries (from March 22) and 34.5% on 2026 entries (to October 8).

S&P 500 ETF: share of entries stopped, by year of entry

S&P 500 ETF: share of entries stopped, by year of entry. 2021, from Jan 25 (238 entries): Stop 2% below entry 51.3%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 50.0%; 2022 (251 entries): Stop 2% below entry 81.3%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 61.0%; 2023 (250 entries): Stop 2% below entry 45.6%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 40.0%; 2024 (252 entries): Stop 2% below entry 41.7%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 41.3%; 2025 (250 entries): Stop 2% below entry 44.0%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 39.6%; 2026, to Sep 30 (187 entries): Stop 2% below entry 58.3%, Stop 2 ATR below entry 57.8%. Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.
  • Stop 2% below entry
  • Stop 2 ATR below entry
Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.Same test as the table above, split by the year of the entry. The ATR stop moves with volatility but does not remove the swings between years.

A stop does not give an edge to a random entry; it changes the shape of the losses. On the ETF, which rose over the window, the average 20-session return of all entries was 1.17% with no stop, 0.99% with an 8% stop, 0.64% with a 2 ATR stop and 0.50% with a 2% stop. On EUR/USD, which fell over its window, it was −0.32% with no stop and −0.17% with a 2 ATR stop. Whether a stop helps depends on what the price does after the entry, which is what your entry rule has to supply.

S&P 500 ETF: average 20-session return of all entries, by stop

S&P 500 ETF: average 20-session return of all entries, by stop. No stop: +1.17%; 8% below entry: +0.99%; 5% below entry: +0.94%; 3 ATR below entry: +0.78%; 2 ATR below entry: +0.64%; 2% below entry: +0.50%; 1 ATR below entry: +0.43%. Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.
Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.1,428 entries from January 25, 2021 to September 30, 2026; a stopped entry counts its exit return, the others their return at the 20th session. On a rising market, the tighter the stop, the more of the rise it gave up.

How to calculate a stop loss

MethodFormulaExample
Percentage of priceEntry × (1 − stop %)Hypothetical: $30 entry, 6% stop: 30 × 0.94 = $28.20
ATR multipleEntry − k × ATR(14)S&P 500 ETF close of Oct 28, 2026: 772.31 − 2 × 6.94 = 758.43, 1.8% below
Short positionEntry × (1 + stop %), or entry + k × ATRHypothetical: $40 short entry, 5% stop: 40 × 1.05 = $42

The ATR line uses the real ETF close and ATR(14) of October 28, 2026; the other two rows are hypothetical. The distance between entry and stop is your risk per share, also called cents or pips at risk. Multiply it by the number of shares to get the account dollars at risk, the number that matters for the account.

Percentage of price is not percentage of the account

Two different percentages are often mixed up. The stop percentage is the distance below the entry price. The account risk is the share of the account you lose if the stop is hit. Hypothetical example: with $10,000 and a 1% account risk, you can lose $100. With a stop 5% below the entry, the position can be $100 ÷ 0.05 = $2,000, or 20% of the account. With a stop 2% below, the same $100 allows a $5,000 position. A wider stop means a smaller position, not a bigger loss. The position sizing guide works through stocks, forex and futures.

Position size from account risk and stop distance

Position size from account risk and stop distance: on the left, the account with the small share risked on one trade. On the right, an entry price and a stop price with the distance between them. Position size equals the amount risked divided by the stop distance.
Schematic, not market data.The amount you accept to lose divided by the stop distance gives the position size, as in the hypothetical example above.

Other ways to place a stop

  • Below structure: under a swing low or a support level for a long, above resistance for a short. We did not test structure stops here, because they need a rule for picking the level. Obvious levels can attract other traders' stops, which stop hunting describes.
  • Trailing: a stop that follows the price up and never moves back, to lock in part of a gain; the trailing stop guide tests trail sizes on the S&P 500 since 1970.
  • Breakeven: moving the stop to the entry price once the trade has moved in your favor. It removes the loss on that trade, but the stop is now inside the noise again and is hit more often.
  • Time: closing a trade that has not moved after a set number of sessions, whatever the price.

How the stop is executed once the price reaches it, and why a stop can fill well below its price after a gap, is a matter of order type: see the stop loss order guide. The distance to the stop also sets the risk side of the risk reward ratio. More risk topics are in trading concepts.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good stop loss percentage?

There is no universal one. The distance has to be wider than the market's ordinary moves: a 2% stop was hit within 20 sessions on 39.2% of random EUR/USD entries and 80.4% of Bitcoin entries in our test. Measuring the distance in ATR, for example 2 ATR, gives a more even result across markets.

What is the 7% rule for stop loss?

It means selling a position if it falls 7% below the purchase price. On the S&P 500 ETF from 2021 to 2026, a 7% stop under a random entry was hit within 20 sessions 11.7% of the time; on Bitcoin from 2025 to 2026, 39.0% of the time. The same rule is loose on an index fund and tight on a volatile asset.

Is 10% a good stop loss?

It depends on the market. A 10% stop was hit within 20 sessions on 5.0% of ETF entries (mostly in 2022), on 22.1% of Bitcoin entries and never on EUR/USD. On a currency pair it is so far away that it rarely acts as a stop at all.

Is a 20% stop loss good?

A 20% stop leaves room for large swings but can lose a fifth of the position when hit. It was never hit within 20 sessions on the ETF or EUR/USD entries we tested, and hit on 8.7% of Bitcoin entries. Size the position so that a 20% fall still costs only the share of the account you accept to lose.

What is the best stop loss percentage for day trading?

We did not test intraday stops: the same logic applies, but on the timeframe you trade. Use the ATR of the intraday bars, for example 14 five-minute bars, rather than a daily percentage, which would be far outside a day trader's normal moves.

How do you calculate a stop loss?

For a percentage stop on a long position: entry × (1 − stop %), so a $30 entry with a 6% stop gives $28.20. For an ATR stop: entry − k × ATR. Then multiply the distance by the number of shares to know the dollars at risk.

What stop loss percentage should I use for swing trading?

Start from the daily ATR of what you trade. On our data, 2 ATR was about 2.3% on the S&P 500 ETF, 5.9% on Bitcoin and 1.6% on EUR/USD at the median. Those are starting points, not recommendations: test the distance with your own entry rule.

Sources

  1. SEC, Investor.gov glossary: Stop Order
  2. SEC, Investor Bulletin: Stop, Stop-Limit, and Trailing Stop Orders (updated August 18, 2026)
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

Related guides

All trading concepts articles