Trading concepts

Fat Finger Trade: What It Is, Documented Errors and the Safeguards

How mistyped orders happen, three cases told from regulators' and courts' records (Citigroup in 2022, Citibank and Revlon in 2020, and the 2010 flash crash that was not one), and the controls that block errors.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 8 min read
Where an input error can still be stopped: five steps of an order. You type the size, price and side, with a small default size. The platform shows a confirmation window, where the value in money can be read. The broker applies price and size limits and rejects duplicate orders, under the SEC market access rule. The exchange executes the trade, which now stands. The exchange or FINRA may void it in a clearly erroneous review, on a short deadline.
On this page
  1. How a fat finger error happens
  2. Documented fat finger cases
  3. The rules that require brokers to block errors
  4. What to do after a fat finger trade
  5. Frequently asked questions

A fat finger trade is an order entered by mistake: a wrong quantity, a wrong price, an extra zero, a sell instead of a buy, or the wrong security. The name comes from the picture of a finger hitting the wrong key. Some are caught at once by the trader or the broker's checks; those that get through can move a whole market for minutes, cost the firm a fine, and leave the trades to be canceled or settled.

Documented cases, from the official records

  1. Flash crash: the SEC and CFTC staffs trace it to an automated sell program of 75,000 E-mini contracts, about $4.1 billion, not to a mistyped order. SEC and CFTC staff report

  2. Citibank, agent on a Revlon loan, sends the $7.8 million of interest due and, by mistake, about $894 million more, the whole principal. SDNY findings of fact

  3. The district court rules that the lenders who received more than $500 million may keep the money. SDNY findings of fact

  4. A Citigroup trader meaning to sell $58 million of equities creates a $444 billion basket; $1.4 billion is sold before cancellation. FCA

  5. The Second Circuit reverses the Revlon ruling: Citibank is entitled to the return of the funds. Citigroup 10-Q

  6. The FCA fines Citigroup Global Markets £27,766,200 and the PRA fines it £33,880,000 for the 2022 error. FCA

Each event links to the source it was checked against.

How a fat finger error happens

  • Quantity or amount: shares typed as dollars, an extra zero, or a field filled in the wrong unit. The Citigroup case below, in 2022, began with an input error in an order management system.
  • Price: a limit price far from the market, which fills at once against every resting order in the way.
  • Side or security: sell instead of buy, or a ticker one letter off.
  • Duplicate orders: the same order sent twice, or a basket released in full when only part was meant.

The risk is higher on screens where an order goes out with one click, and in automated systems where one wrong input is repeated many times before anyone looks.

Documented fat finger cases

Citigroup, May 2, 2022. According to the UK Financial Conduct Authority, a trader at Citigroup Global Markets Limited meant to sell a basket of equities worth $58 million but made an input error that created a basket worth $444 billion. The firm's controls blocked $255 billion of it; the remaining $189 billion went to a trading algorithm, and $1.4 billion of shares were sold on European exchanges before the trader canceled the order. The FCA found that "some primary controls were absent or deficient": there was no hard block to reject the whole basket, and the trader could override a warning without reading it in full. On May 22, 2024 the FCA fined the firm £27,766,200 and the Prudential Regulation Authority fined it £33,880,000 (FCA press release).

Citigroup, May 2, 2022: from the intended order to the shares sold

Citigroup, May 2, 2022: from the intended order to the shares sold. Basket the trader meant to sell: $58 million; Basket created by the input error: $444 bn; Blocked by the firm's controls: $255 bn; Sent to the trading algorithm: $189 bn; Sold on European exchanges: $1.4 bn. Values as published by the source below. Logarithmic scale: equal distances mean equal ratios, and each power of ten sits the same distance from the next.
Values as published by the source below. Logarithmic scale: equal distances mean equal ratios, and each power of ten sits the same distance from the next. Source: FCA, press release of May 22, 2024.The basket created was about 7,700 times the intended one; most of it never reached the market.

Citibank and the Revlon loan, August 11, 2020. This was a payment error rather than a trade, and it shows how far a wrong input can go. As agent on a Revlon term loan, Citibank meant to pass about $7.8 million of interest to the lenders and also sent, from its own funds, an amount equal to the whole outstanding principal, about $894 million, according to the findings of the federal court in New York. Lenders holding about $504 million refused to return it. The district court ruled for them in February 2021 (SDNY findings of fact); the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed that ruling on September 8, 2022 and held that Citibank was entitled to the money back, as Citigroup reported in its quarterly filing (Citigroup 10-Q, legal proceedings).

May 6, 2010, the flash crash: not a fat finger. The joint report of the SEC and CFTC staffs found something else: a mutual fund complex sold 75,000 E-mini S&P 500 futures contracts, worth about $4.1 billion, through an automated program set to trade 9% of the volume of the previous minute, without regard to price or time (SEC and CFTC, Findings regarding the market events of May 6, 2010). The order was intended; the way it was executed was the problem. A large, fast move is not proof of a fat finger.

The rules that require brokers to block errors

In the United States, SEC Rule 15c3-5, the market access rule, requires a broker that gives access to an exchange to have controls that "prevent the entry of erroneous orders, by rejecting orders that exceed appropriate price or size parameters, on an order-by-order basis or over a short period of time, or that indicate duplicative orders" (17 CFR 240.15c3-5). These are the kind of hard blocks the FCA, under UK rules, found missing at Citigroup.

Where an input error can still be stopped

Where an input error can still be stopped: five steps of an order. You type the size, price and side, with a small default size. The platform shows a confirmation window, where the value in money can be read. The broker applies price and size limits and rejects duplicate orders, under the SEC market access rule. The exchange executes the trade, which now stands. The exchange or FINRA may void it in a clearly erroneous review, on a short deadline.

When an erroneous trade does execute, it is not always final. Exchanges and FINRA have clearly erroneous execution rules. FINRA Rule 11892 covers over-the-counter trades in exchange-listed stocks, and its limits are narrower than they look. During normal market hours, a trade in a stock covered by the Limit Up-Limit Down plan, which keeps prices inside bands, is generally not reviewable as clearly erroneous, apart from exceptions such as a member's systems issue or a trade after a halt. The numerical guidelines apply to the other cases: a trade at least 10% away from the reference price for stocks up to $25, 5% up to $50 and 3% above, during normal hours, and twice those distances outside them. A FINRA officer acts generally within 30 minutes of becoming aware of the trade (FINRA Rule 11892).

FINRA Rule 11892: distance from the reference price for a clearly erroneous trade

FINRA Rule 11892: distance from the reference price for a clearly erroneous trade. Stock price up to $25: Normal hours, reviewable cases 10% away, Outside normal hours 20% away; Over $25, up to $50: Normal hours, reviewable cases 5% away, Outside normal hours 10% away; Over $50: Normal hours, reviewable cases 3% away, Outside normal hours 6% away. Values as published by the source below.
  • Normal hours, reviewable cases
  • Outside normal hours
Values as published by the source below. Source: FINRA Rule 11892, numerical guidelines.During normal hours most listed stocks trade inside Limit Up-Limit Down bands and their trades are generally not reviewable; the first series covers the cases the rule still lets FINRA review.

A trade that is not canceled stays the trader's loss or gain.

What to do after a fat finger trade

  1. Stop the order first. Cancel what has not filled; an order that is partially filled is still working, and every second counts.
  2. Call the broker at once. Only the broker or the exchange can ask for a review as clearly erroneous, and the time to do it is short.
  3. Decide on the position you now hold. If the trade stands, the position is real: close it, or hedge it, under your usual risk rules, not under the shock of the error.
  4. Write down what happened. The order, the time and the fills help with the broker and with your own records.

More on execution and orders in trading concepts.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

What is a fat finger trade?

An order entered by mistake: the wrong size, price, side or security, typically from a typing or input error. It can be canceled before it fills; once filled, it stands unless the exchange or FINRA declares it clearly erroneous.

What was the biggest fat finger error?

We do not rank them, because the size depends on how it is measured. Among documented cases, the Citigroup error of May 2, 2022 created a $444 billion sell basket, of which $1.4 billion was executed, according to the FCA.

Can a fat finger trade be reversed?

Sometimes, and less often than traders hope. Exchanges and FINRA can cancel clearly erroneous trades under their rules, but during normal hours most listed stocks trade inside Limit Up-Limit Down bands and their trades are generally not reviewable. Call your broker at once; a trade that is not canceled stays on your account.

Was the 2010 flash crash a fat finger?

No. The joint SEC and CFTC staff report attributed the start of the fall to an automated program selling 75,000 E-mini S&P 500 contracts at 9% of the previous minute's volume, without regard to price or time.

Sources

  1. FCA, FCA fines CGML £27,766,200 for failures in its trading systems and controls, May 22, 2024
  2. US District Court, SDNY, In re Citibank August 11, 2020 Wire Transfers, findings of fact and conclusions of law, February 16, 2021
  3. Citigroup, quarterly report on Form 10-Q, legal proceedings (Revlon wire transfers)
  4. Staffs of the CFTC and SEC, Findings Regarding the Market Events of May 6, 2010
  5. 17 CFR 240.15c3-5, Risk management controls for brokers or dealers with market access
  6. FINRA Rule 11892, Clearly Erroneous Transactions in Exchange-Listed Securities
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

All trading concepts articles