Trading concepts

Discretionary Trader: What It Means, How It Differs From a Systematic Trader, and Discretionary Accounts

Judgment against written rules, why only one of them can be backtested, how a discretionary trader can measure their own edge, and what FINRA Rule 3260 says about accounts where a broker trades for you.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 5 min read
The same decision, by judgment or by rule: two rows. Discretionary: chart, context and news go to a trader who judges case by case, then buys, sells or waits; rerun the same day, the call can differ. Systematic: the same bars go to a written rule that decides; rerun the same day, the call is the same. Only the rule can be backtested; judgment is measured afterward, in a trade journal.
On this page
  1. Discretionary vs. systematic trading
  2. How a discretionary trader can work with discipline
  3. Discretionary accounts: the legal meaning
  4. Frequently asked questions

A discretionary trader decides each trade by judgment: they read the chart, the news and the market's behavior, and choose when to enter, where to exit and how much to risk, case by case. A systematic trader writes those decisions as fixed rules in advance and follows them, often through a program. A trader can also combine the two, using written rules for some decisions and judgment for others. The word "discretionary" has a second, legal meaning in a brokerage account, where it describes a broker trading for a customer without asking each time; that is covered further down, with FINRA's rule.

The same decision, by judgment or by rule

The same decision, by judgment or by rule: two rows. Discretionary: chart, context and news go to a trader who judges case by case, then buys, sells or waits; rerun the same day, the call can differ. Systematic: the same bars go to a written rule that decides; rerun the same day, the call is the same. Only the rule can be backtested; judgment is measured afterward, in a trade journal.
Why only the systematic version can be backtested: rerun on the same day, a written rule gives the same call.

Discretionary vs. systematic trading

AspectDiscretionary traderSystematic trader
How a trade is chosenJudgment on each setup, which can weigh information no rule anticipatedA written rule; the same inputs always give the same trade
Can it be backtested?Not fully: past judgment cannot be replayed without hindsightYes, on past prices, with the usual pitfalls
Main riskInconsistency: fear, hope and fatigue change the decisionA rule fitted to the past that stops working

The deciding difference is the second row. A systematic rule can be run on past data to see how it would have done; the backtesting page explains how, and which pitfalls make a test look better than the rule. A discretionary decision cannot: when you look back at a chart you already know what happened next, so a "replay" of your judgment is not a test. That makes a discretionary trader's real track record, kept trade by trade, the only evidence of their edge.

How a discretionary trader can work with discipline

  • Write down what is fixed. Risk per trade, maximum daily loss and the markets traded can be rules even when entries are judgment calls. The trading plan page lists the parts of a written plan.
  • Record the reason for every trade at the time, before the result is known, then compare reasons with results after enough trades. See tracking trading performance.
  • Record the trades you skipped, as in the example above, so that the judgment itself can be measured.
  • Turn what works into rules. A judgment that keeps being right in the record can often be written as a condition and tested.

What a trade-by-trade record can show

A trading diary, and what its review shows: a table with one line per trade: why I entered, why I exited, result. Two lines read breakout or pullback, planned, with a small loss or a gain. Two lines read bored, no setup, exited in a panic, large loss. An arrow leads to the review: the same entry reason keeps ending in the same loss.
Schematic, not market data.A diary kept at the time of each trade, reasons included, is the only evidence of a discretionary edge; recording skipped setups measures the judgment itself.

In a brokerage account, "discretion" means the authority for a broker to trade for a customer without asking before each trade. FINRA Rule 3260 governs it (FINRA Rule 3260, Discretionary Accounts):

  • Written authorization. No member or registered representative may exercise discretionary power in a customer's account "unless such customer has given prior written authorization to a stated individual or individuals and the account has been accepted by the member," as evidenced in writing.
  • Review. The firm must approve each discretionary order promptly in writing and review discretionary accounts at frequent intervals to detect and prevent transactions "excessive in size or frequency in view of the financial resources and character of the account."
  • Time and price only. The rule does not apply to discretion only over the price or the time at which a customer's order for a definite amount of a specified security is executed; that authority lasts only until the end of the business day on which it was granted, unless the customer signs and dates a written contrary instruction.

What FINRA's rule requires of a discretionary account

What FINRA's rule on discretionary accounts requires: left, the steps of a discretionary account: the customer gives prior written authorization, the firm accepts the account in writing, each discretionary order is approved promptly in writing, and the account is reviewed often so that trading is not excessive. Right, outside the rule: when the customer sets the security and the amount and the broker picks only the time or the price, that discretion ends with the business day it was given, unless the customer signs otherwise.
FINRA rule on discretionary accounts, paragraphs (a) to (d), simplified.The rule text linked above has the exact conditions.

So a "discretionary order" in the legal sense is an order where the customer leaves the broker some choice, for example of the time and price of execution; in the trading sense, a discretionary trader is anyone who decides their own trades by judgment. More trading terms are on the trading concepts page.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

What is discretionary trading vs. systematic trading?

Discretionary trading decides each trade by judgment; systematic trading follows fixed rules written in advance, often run by a program. A trader can combine the two.

What is the difference between discretionary and non-discretionary trading?

In the trading sense, non-discretionary means rule-based. In a brokerage account, a non-discretionary account is one where the broker must get your approval before each trade, while a discretionary account lets the broker trade without asking, under FINRA Rule 3260.

What is a discretionary order in law?

An order where the customer leaves some choice to the broker. Under FINRA Rule 3260, discretion only over the time and price of an order for a definite amount of a specified security falls outside the rule's main requirements and lasts until the end of that business day unless the customer instructs otherwise in writing.

Can a discretionary trader backtest their strategy?

Not in the full sense, because past judgment cannot be replayed without knowing what came next. Parts that are written as rules can be tested; the rest is measured by keeping a record of every trade and every skipped setup.

Is discretionary or systematic trading better?

The site has no evidence that one style earns more in general. A systematic rule is easier to test; a discretionary approach is only as good as its recorded results show.

Sources

  1. FINRA Rule 3260, Discretionary Accounts
  2. Investor.gov (SEC), Churning
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

Related guides

All trading concepts articles