Trading concepts

Choppy Market: How to Identify a Ranging Market and Trade It

How the Choppiness Index and the ADX measure chop, both read on the S&P 500 ETF in 2026, a 33-year test of what chop does to moving average signals, and how traders handle a range.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 7 min read
Choppiness Index(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, August 5, 2026 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.
On this page
  1. How to identify a choppy market
  2. Trend signals in choppy and trending markets, tested
  3. How to trade a ranging market
  4. Frequently asked questions

A choppy market, or ranging market, is one in which prices move back and forth without making progress: rallies fail, dips are bought, and the price ends the week near where it started. Traders call it choppy because the chart looks like a saw blade, and they fear it because trend-following tools, moving average crosses and breakouts, keep giving signals that reverse. This page shows how two indicators measure chop, the Choppiness Index and the ADX, on the S&P 500 ETF in 2026, and what 33 years of the same ETF say about trend signals in choppy and trending conditions.

Choppiness Index (14) on the S&P 500 ETF, March to October 2026

Choppiness Index(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, March 26, 2026 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.
  • Price, daily candles (hollow up, filled down)
  • CHOP(14) (solid line)
Choppiness Index(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, March 26, 2026 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.

How to identify a choppy market

By eye, a ranging market shows a flat or sideways sequence of highs and lows, prices that cross a moving average again and again, and candles that overlap. Two indicators turn that impression into a number:

  • The Choppiness Index (CHOP): compares the distance the price traveled, the sum of the true ranges over 14 bars, with the ground it covered, the highest high minus the lowest low. Created by the Australian commodity trader E.W. Dreiss, it reads near 100 when the price goes back and forth and near 0 in a straight move. TradingView describes readings above 61.8 as choppy, sideways territory and readings below 38.2 as a trending market, the two levels drawn on the chart.
  • The ADX, part of the directional movement index: measures the strength of the trend, whatever its direction. Its creator, Welles Wilder, read an ADX above 25 as a strong trend and below 20 as no trend, with a gray zone in between, according to StockCharts; those are the levels drawn on its chart.

The chart above covers the last 150 sessions of the S&P 500 ETF, from March 26 to October 28, 2026. CHOP rose above 61.8 only on July 20 to 22 (high of 70.2). On October 28 it read 59.3, after 40 sessions in which the ETF traded between a low of 747.74 and a high of 781.62, a range of 4.5%. A narrow sideways range after a move is what traders call consolidation in stocks, and it ends with a breakout up or down.

ADX and directional indicators (14) on the S&P 500 ETF, same sessions

DMI(14), ADX(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, March 26, 2026 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.
  • Price, daily candles (hollow up, filled down)
  • +DI(14) (solid line)
  • −DI(14) (solid line, second color)
  • ADX(14) (dashed line)
DMI(14), ADX(14) on S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted prices, daily, March 26, 2026 to October 28, 2026. Illustration of how the indicator reads, not a backtest.

The ADX over the same sessions tells a similar but not identical story. It peaked at 40.7 on March 30, during the spring decline, and was below 20 on 58 of the 150 sessions, including October 28 (13.7). Over the window, every session with CHOP above 61.8 also had an ADX below 20, but most sessions with a low ADX did not have a high CHOP: the two measures lean the same way, but the high CHOP reading is much rarer, so the two flags overlap only in part.

To see what chop does to a trend-following rule, we took the S&P 500 ETF from November 15, 1993 to October 27, 2026, 8,293 sessions with dividend-adjusted prices, and classified each session by its CHOP(14) and its ADX(14), the ADX built on Wilder’s averages as on the chart above. A cross is a session whose close sits on the other side of its 50-day simple moving average from the previous close. The trend rule earns the next session’s close to close return when the close is above the average and nothing otherwise; buy and hold earns the next session’s return every time. For each group we counted the crosses and averaged both returns over its sessions.

Closes crossing the 50-day average, per 100 sessions

Closes crossing the 50-day average, per 100 sessions. CHOP above 61.8 (6.5% of sessions): 8.92; CHOP 38.2 to 61.8 (77.6%): 8.00; CHOP below 38.2 (15.9%): 1.59; ADX below 20 (40.5%): 10.60; ADX 20 to 25 (23.7%): 7.36; ADX above 25 (35.8%): 2.80. Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.
Our computation; the inputs and the method are in the text.S&P 500 ETF, dividend-adjusted daily closes, 8,293 sessions from November 15, 1993 to October 27, 2026, grouped by CHOP(14) and ADX(14). Choppy readings came with four to six times more crosses than trending ones.

The clear result is in the crossing counts: the price crossed its 50-day average about four to six times more often in choppy conditions (CHOP above 61.8, ADX below 20) than in trending ones. Each cross is a buy or sell signal for a moving average rule, so chop multiplies trades, costs and false starts. Part of the gap is built in, since both indicators rise or fall with the back-and-forth movement that produces crosses.

GroupTrend rule, next dayBuy and hold, next day
CHOP above 61.8+0.019%+0.062%
CHOP from 38.2 to 61.8+0.020%+0.042%
CHOP below 38.2+0.033%+0.071%
ADX below 20+0.023%+0.021%
ADX above 25+0.018%+0.071%

The mean next-day returns are less clear. The trend rule earned less than buy and hold in every group except ADX below 20, where the two were about equal, because being out of the market on many rising days costs more than the falls it avoids. By CHOP, the trend rule earned less in choppy sessions (+0.019%) than in trending ones (+0.033%); by ADX it was the reverse (+0.023% with a low ADX, +0.018% with a high one). The two measures do not agree, and the differences are small next to a daily move of about 1%. The common advice to stop using trend tools in chop is supported by the number of signals, not by a consistent difference in their average result.

How to trade a ranging market

Trading a range: edges, stops and the breakout

Trading a range: edges, stops and the breakout: a price path bouncing between a resistance line and a support line. A shaded buy zone sits just above support and a shaded sell zone just below resistance; the middle is marked no trade. Dashed stop lines sit just outside the range. At the right, the path breaks out above resistance, which ends the range.
Schematic, not market data.
  • Trade the edges, not the middle. In a range, the buy zone is near support and the sell zone near resistance; the support and resistance guide covers how to mark them, and the rectangle pattern is the chart figure of a range.
  • Use tools built for ranges. Oscillators such as the Relative Strength Index and mean reversion rules assume the price comes back to the middle; a grid is the mechanical version.
  • Trade smaller and less often. With more signals that reverse, costs and stop outs pile up; reducing size keeps a run of small losses affordable, and the position size guide shows how.
  • Plan for the end of the range. Every range ends in a breakout; a stop beyond the range protects a range trade, and a falling CHOP or a rising ADX shows the market leaving the range.

More on market conditions in trading concepts and in our indicators section.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

What is a choppy market?

A market that moves back and forth without a clear direction, so rallies and declines reverse quickly. It is also called a ranging or sideways market. The Choppiness Index above 61.8 or an ADX below 20 are two numeric tests that put a number on it.

How do you identify a choppy market?

On the chart: flat highs and lows, overlapping candles and a price that crosses its moving average often. With indicators: a Choppiness Index (14) above 61.8, or an ADX (14) below 20. The two often disagree, so pick one and define the threshold.

Do moving averages work in a choppy market?

They give many more signals. On the S&P 500 ETF from 1993 to 2026, the price crossed its 50-day average 10.6 times per 100 sessions when the ADX was below 20, against 2.8 when it was above 25. More crosses mean more trades and more costs.

What indicator is best for a choppy market?

To detect chop, the Choppiness Index and the ADX. To trade inside a range, traders use oscillators such as the RSI and support and resistance levels. No indicator tells you when the range will end.

Sources

  1. TradingView Help Center, Choppiness Index (CHOP)
  2. StockCharts ChartSchool, Average Directional Index (ADX)
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

All trading concepts articles