Trading concepts

Buy Wall vs. Sell Wall: What They Are, How to Spot Them, and When They Are Spoofing

How a large resting order shows up in an order book, why a wall can hold, be pulled or be fake, how U.S. law defines spoofing, and why price bars cannot test walls.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 9 min read
Order book: bids, asks and the spread: a price ladder with resting sell orders (asks) above and resting buy orders (bids) below, each level drawn as a bar sized by the quantity waiting there; the best ask and best bid frame the spread and the mid price.
On this page
  1. What a wall is in an order book
  2. Buy wall vs. sell wall
  3. Three things a wall can turn out to be
  4. When a wall is spoofing
  5. What the site can and cannot test
  6. How traders read walls, and the limits
  7. Frequently asked questions

A buy wall is an unusually large quantity of buy orders resting at one price, or a few neighboring prices, in an order book; a sell wall is the same on the sell side. On a depth chart the cumulative quantity jumps at that price. A wall is a picture of orders that are still waiting, and an order that waits can be canceled, so a wall is information about intentions, not about trades. This page explains how walls form, what they can and cannot tell you, why regulators treat some of them as spoofing, and why the site has no order book data to test them.

A schematic order book

Order book: bids, asks and the spread: a price ladder with resting sell orders (asks) above and resting buy orders (bids) below, each level drawn as a bar sized by the quantity waiting there; the best ask and best bid frame the spread and the mid price.
Schematic, not market data.Relative quantities, not real data: bids below the price, asks above, one bar per price level. A wall is a level whose bar is much longer than its neighbors.

What a wall is in an order book

An order book lists the limit orders waiting to trade: bids, the buyers, below the current price and asks, the sellers, above it. Each line shows a price and the quantity waiting there. The depth of market page explains the screen line by line, and level 2 stock data is the same view for stocks. A depth chart draws the book as two staircases, the cumulative bids on one side and the cumulative asks on the other.

A wall is a level where the waiting quantity is much larger than at the levels around it. There is no official threshold: "much larger" is a judgment by the person reading the book, which is one reason two traders can disagree on whether a wall is there. To see walls at all, you need the order book screen of your broker or exchange, shown as level 2 data or as a depth chart; a price chart does not show resting orders. On a depth chart, a wall is a step much taller than the steps around it.

A buy wall and a sell wall on a depth chart

How a wall shows on a depth chart: a depth chart: from the mid price, the bids add up as a green staircase to the left and the asks as a red staircase to the right. Each price level adds a small step, except one bid level and one ask level that add a much taller step: the buy wall and the sell wall.
Schematic, not market data. Quantities are relative.The staircases add up the waiting quantity level by level from the mid price; a wall is the one level that adds a step several times taller than its neighbors.

Buy wall vs. sell wall

A buy wall sits below the price. For the price to fall through it, sellers have to fill the whole quantity waiting there, so while it stays in place it can slow a decline. A sell wall sits above the price: buyers have to absorb it before the price can rise past it, so it can cap a rally for as long as it stays. That is all the mechanism says. A sell wall does not push prices up, and a buy wall does not push prices down; and neither says what will happen once it is filled, canceled or moved.

Three things a wall can turn out to be

The same picture in the book can come from very different orders, and the book alone does not say which.

  • A real order that trades. A participant who wants to buy or sell a large quantity at that price leaves it there and gets filled. This is the case where the wall behaves like support or resistance.
  • A real order that leaves. The owner changes their mind, or moves the order to another price. The wall was genuine and still did not hold.
  • An order placed to be canceled. The quantity is shown to make other traders believe in demand or supply that does not exist. U.S. law calls this spoofing, described below.

A wall can also be bigger than it looks. An iceberg order shows only part of its quantity, so a level that looks ordinary can keep refilling as it trades. And a wall can be eaten in pieces: a large order can be partially filled, so the wall shrinks before it disappears.

Three things the same buy wall can turn out to be

Three things the same buy wall can turn out to be: three panels with the same buy wall under a falling price. In the first, the wall is a real order that trades and the price bounces off it. In the second, a real order is withdrawn and the price falls through where it was. In the third, the order was placed to be canceled and the price falls through the same way: the second and third look the same on the screen.
Schematic, not market data.The book shows the wall, not the intent behind it: a real order that leaves and an order placed to be canceled disappear the same way.

When a wall is spoofing

The Commodity Exchange Act makes it unlawful to engage in any trading, practice or conduct on or subject to the rules of a registered entity that "is, is of the character of, or is commonly known to the trade as, 'spoofing' (bidding or offering with the intent to cancel the bid or offer before execution)" (7 U.S.C. 6c(a)(5)(C)). The test is the intent to cancel, which is why a wall that disappears is not proof of spoofing by itself: real orders get canceled too. The U.S. futures regulator's own cases show what spoofed walls looked like.

DateCaseWhat the CFTC described
April 21, 2015Charges against Navinder Singh Sarao, E-mini S&P 500 futures (release 7156-15)A "layering algorithm" placing large sell orders at several price levels above the best ask, mostly canceled, on over 400 trading days from April 2010 to April 2015; the complaint alleged that it contributed to the market conditions of the May 6, 2010 Flash Crash.
November 17, 2016Consent order in the same case (release 7486-16)Four to six exceptionally large sell orders, one price point apart, starting at least three or four price points from the best ask, modified hundreds of times to avoid execution. Civil monetary penalty of $25,743,174.52 and disgorgement of $12,871,587.26, more than $38 million, plus permanent trading and registration bans.
September 29, 2020Order against JPMorgan (release 8260-20)Hundreds of thousands of spoof orders in precious metals and U.S. Treasury futures over at least eight years, placed "with the intent to cancel those orders prior to execution" and sending "false signals of supply or demand." $920.2 million, which the CFTC called the largest monetary relief it had ever imposed.

Sanctions ordered in the two CFTC spoofing cases, in millions of dollars

Sanctions ordered in the two CFTC spoofing cases, in millions of dollars. Sarao, civil monetary penalty (2016): $25.7M; Sarao, disgorgement (2016): $12.9M; JPMorgan, total monetary relief (2020): $920.2M. Values as published by the source below. Logarithmic scale: equal distances mean equal ratios, and each power of ten sits the same distance from the next.
Values as published by the source below. Logarithmic scale: equal distances mean equal ratios, and each power of ten sits the same distance from the next. Source: CFTC, releases 7486-16 (November 17, 2016) and 8260-20 (September 29, 2020).Sarao's two amounts, ordered by a federal court in Chicago at the CFTC's request, add up to more than $38 million; the JPMorgan figure is the total the CFTC called the largest monetary relief it had ever imposed. Rounded to one decimal.

Those cases were proven with order records that showed each order's life, not with screenshots of a book. A trader looking at a depth chart sees none of that record.

What the site can and cannot test

How traders read walls, and the limits

  • Watch what the wall does, not that it exists. A wall that is hit and keeps trading is absorbing real orders; one that steps back each time the price approaches is behaving like an order that does not want to be filled.
  • Check the tape. Trades printed at the wall's price confirm that it is filling. A wall with no trades against it is still only a quote.
  • Remember what the book does not show. Hidden and iceberg quantity is not displayed, other venues have their own books, and orders can arrive faster than a screen refreshes.
  • Do not hang a stop just behind a visible wall. If the wall is pulled, the price can reach the stop without trading at the wall at all. See the stop-loss order page for how stops fill.

Other order book and order flow terms, from the spread to the imbalance, are gathered on the trading concepts page.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

What is a buy wall?

An unusually large quantity of buy orders waiting at one price, or a few close prices, below the current price. Sellers have to fill it before the price can fall below that level, as long as the orders stay in the book.

What is a sell wall?

The mirror image: a large quantity of sell orders waiting above the current price. Buyers have to absorb it before the price can rise past it. It does not push prices up or down by itself.

How do you spot a sell wall?

On the order book or depth chart of your broker or exchange: a sell wall is an ask level whose waiting quantity is much larger than the levels around it, a tall step on the ask side of a depth chart. Then watch whether trades print against it or whether it moves away as the price approaches.

Are buy and sell walls fake?

Some are real orders and some are not. A wall can be filled, pulled by an owner who changed their mind, or placed with the intent to cancel it, which U.S. law calls spoofing. The order book alone does not tell you which.

Is placing a wall illegal?

Placing a large order you intend to trade is legal. Placing bids or offers with the intent to cancel them before execution is spoofing, which the Commodity Exchange Act prohibits on registered entities, and the CFTC has brought cases for it.

Do buy walls work as support?

Only while the orders stay in the book and only up to their size. The site has no order book data, so it cannot give a rate at which walls hold; treat any such rate without order data with caution.

Sources

  1. 7 U.S. Code § 6c, Prohibited transactions (Cornell Legal Information Institute)
  2. CFTC, release 7156-15, charges for manipulation and spoofing in E-mini S&P 500 futures, April 21, 2015
  3. CFTC, release 7486-16, consent order with Navinder Singh Sarao, November 17, 2016
  4. CFTC, release 8260-20, JPMorgan to pay $920 million for spoofing, September 29, 2020
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

All trading concepts articles