Trading conceptsOptions

Buy to Open vs Buy to Close: Options Orders Explained

The four options order instructions side by side, with payoff charts for opening long and short, worked closing examples, the effect of each order on open interest, and which instruction fits which goal.

· Founder of PatternsWizard
Checked 8 min read
Long call (buy to open). Hypothetical example: long 1 call, strike 50.00, premium 2.50; underlying at 50.00 when the position is opened. Profit and loss at expiration, before commissions and taxes. Values per share.
On this page
  1. The four options order instructions
  2. Buy to open: paying for the right
  3. Sell to open, then buy to close: the writer's side
  4. Closing a trade without exercise or assignment
  5. How opening and closing orders change open interest
  6. Buy at the open vs buy at the close: on-open and on-close orders
  7. Which one to choose
  8. Frequently asked questions

Buy to open starts a new long options position: you pay the premium and now own the contract. Buy to close ends a short options position you already have: you buy back a contract you sold earlier, and your obligation as a writer disappears. Both are buy orders; the difference is whether the trade creates a position or cancels one.

The same split exists on the sell side, which gives four order instructions in all. Options orders carry one of them because the same click, "buy one call", can mean entering a bet or leaving one, and the risks are not the same.

The four options order instructions

The Options Industry Council separates opening transactions, which initiate or increase an options position, from closing transactions, which reduce or eliminate one (OIC, Options Overview for Investors). Crossed with buying and selling, that gives the four instructions below.

InstructionWhat you had beforeWhat you have afterCash
Buy to openNo position (or an existing long)A long option, or a bigger oneYou pay the premium
Sell to closeA long optionA smaller long, or noneYou receive the premium
Sell to openNo position (or an existing short)A short option: you are the writerYou receive the premium
Buy to closeA short optionA smaller short, or noneYou pay the premium

The pairs go together: a position opened with buy to open is closed with sell to close, and a position opened with sell to open is closed with buy to close. A standard equity option covers 100 shares, so a premium quoted at 2.50 costs or brings in $250 per contract.

Which order opens and which closes each options position

Which order opens and which closes each options position: two rows. Top row, a long option: buy to open, then you hold the right, then sell to close; you pay the premium and receive the closing premium when you sell. Bottom row, a short option: sell to open, then you carry the obligation and the assignment risk, then buy to close; you receive the premium and pay to buy the contract back. Either position can also end at expiration or by exercise or assignment.

Buy to open: paying for the right

When you buy to open a call, you get the right to buy 100 shares at the strike price until the option expires; a put gives the right to sell them. The most you can lose is the premium you paid. The chart shows a hypothetical example: a call with a 50 strike bought to open for 2.50.

Hypothetical: 50 call bought to open for 2.50, breakeven 52.50

Hypothetical example: long 1 call, strike 50.00, premium 2.50; underlying at 50.00 when the position is opened. Profit and loss at expiration, before commissions and taxes. Values per share. Net premium: 2.50 paid (net debit). Maximum gain: Unlimited. Maximum loss: 2.50, at 50.00 and below. Break-even price: 52.50.
Net premium2.50 paid (net debit)
Maximum gainUnlimited
Maximum loss2.50, at 50.00 and below
Break-even price52.50
  • Profit or loss at expiration
  • Gain
  • Loss
  • Strike (K)
  • Break-even
Hypothetical example: long 1 call, strike 50.00, premium 2.50; underlying at 50.00 when the position is opened. Profit and loss at expiration, before commissions and taxes. Values per share.

At expiration, this position loses the full premium below 50, breaks even at 52.50 and gains above that. Before expiration, its value moves with the stock price, the time left and volatility, which is what the option Greeks measure. Whether the strike is above or below the stock price is covered in in the money vs out of the money.

Sell to open, then buy to close: the writer's side

Selling to open makes you the writer. You collect the premium now and take on the obligation: for a call, to sell 100 shares at the strike if the holder exercises. The OIC notes that the writer of an uncovered call or put that is not cash-secured "must meet applicable margin requirements", and that writers are exposed to assignment. Here is the same 50 call, this time sold to open for 2.50.

Hypothetical: 50 call sold to open for 2.50, breakeven 52.50

Hypothetical example: short 1 call, strike 50.00, premium 2.50; underlying at 50.00 when the position is opened. Profit and loss at expiration, before commissions and taxes. Values per share. Net premium: 2.50 received (net credit). Maximum gain: 2.50, at 50.00 and below. Maximum loss: Unlimited. Break-even price: 52.50.
Net premium2.50 received (net credit)
Maximum gain2.50, at 50.00 and below
Maximum lossUnlimited
Break-even price52.50
  • Profit or loss at expiration
  • Gain
  • Loss
  • Strike (K)
  • Break-even
Hypothetical example: short 1 call, strike 50.00, premium 2.50; underlying at 50.00 when the position is opened. Profit and loss at expiration, before commissions and taxes. Values per share.

The profit is capped at the 2.50 received, and the loss above 52.50 has no ceiling. Buy to close is how a writer gets out before expiration: buying back the same contract cancels the obligation, whatever the stock does afterward. This is the order that writers of covered calls or cash-secured puts use when they want to take profit early or step aside before an event; see selling options premium.

Closing a trade without exercise or assignment

An options position does not have to end with an exercise. In the OIC's words, "upon the execution of a closing transaction, the investor can capture a realized gain or loss on the investment without entering the exercise or assignment process". The two hypothetical examples below show the arithmetic, before commissions and fees.

Hypothetical: the short 50 call sold at 2.50, bought back or held

Hypothetical: the short 50 call sold at 2.50, bought back or held. Buy to close at 1.00 before expiration: +$150; Held, stock at 50 or below at expiration: +$250; Held, stock at 52.50 at expiration: $0; Held, stock at 55 at expiration: −$250; Held, stock at 60 at expiration: −$750. Hypothetical example, computed from the assumptions in the text.
Hypothetical example, computed from the assumptions in the text.Hypothetical example from the text, one standard contract of 100 shares, before commissions and fees. Buying to close fixes the result; holding leaves it to the stock price at expiration, with no limit on the loss.

How opening and closing orders change open interest

Open interest is the number of contracts still open at the end of the day; the OCC calculates it (OIC, Open interest: why it matters). Whether a trade adds to it depends on both sides of the trade, not just on yours.

BuyerSellerOpen interest
Buy to openSell to openRises by the number of contracts
Sell to close (exiting a long)Buy to close (exiting a short)Falls by the number of contracts
Buy to openSell to closeUnchanged: the contract changes hands
Buy to closeSell to openUnchanged: one writer replaces another

Volume counts every contract traded; only the change in open interest shows whether those trades opened positions or closed them.

Buy at the open vs buy at the close: on-open and on-close orders

For stocks, "buy open" and "buy close" can also mean an order to buy at the opening price or at the closing price of the session. On Nasdaq these are on-open orders (market-on-open, MOO, and limit-on-open, LOO) and on-close orders (market-on-close, MOC, and limit-on-close, LOC): they execute only in the Opening Cross at 9:30 a.m. ET or the Closing Cross at 4:00 p.m. ET, two auctions that cross the orders at a single price. The Opening Cross sets the Nasdaq Official Opening Price and the Closing Cross the Nasdaq Official Closing Price (Nasdaq, Opening and Closing Cross FAQ).

OrderFills atDeadline (ET)
MOOThe open, any priceBefore 9:28 a.m.
LOOThe open, within your limitUntil 9:29:30 a.m.
MOCThe close, any priceBefore 3:55 p.m.
LOCThe close, within your limitBefore 3:58 p.m.

Before each auction, between 9:25 and 9:28 a.m. and between 3:50 and 3:55 p.m., Nasdaq publishes every 10 seconds the reference price, the number of shares already paired and the size and side of any imbalance. The morning part, from 9:25, is the early order imbalance indicator the SEC approved on April 2, 2021 (SEC Release No. 34-91461); from 9:28 Nasdaq adds the indicative clearing prices. Late limit orders are accepted with conditions: a LOO entered after 9:28 a.m. or a LOC entered after 3:55 p.m. is repriced if its limit is more aggressive than the prices Nasdaq has already published. A market-on-close order fills at a price you do not know when you send it, which is the trade-off for getting the official close. The timeline below puts the Nasdaq deadlines in order. Other exchanges run their own auctions with their own deadlines; check your broker's order ticket for the venue.

Order cutoffs before the Nasdaq Opening and Closing Crosses

Order cutoffs before the Nasdaq Opening and Closing Crosses: two timelines in New York time. Morning: imbalance data starts and the last change or cancel at 9:25, the last market-on-open order at 9:28, the last limit-on-open order at 9:29:30, and the Opening Cross at 9:30. Afternoon: imbalance data starts and the last change or cancel at 3:50, the last market-on-close order at 3:55, the last limit-on-close order at 3:58, and the Closing Cross at 4:00.
From Nasdaq's Opening and Closing Cross FAQ and the SEC order approving the early imbalance data; late limit orders are accepted with conditions.

Ordinary market, limit and stop orders are covered in order types, and the first minutes of trading after the opening auction in the opening range guide.

Which one to choose

  • You want to bet on a move with a known maximum loss: buy to open a call or a put.
  • You hold a long option and want out: sell to close.
  • You want to collect premium and accept an obligation: sell to open, with the margin or the shares or cash to cover it.
  • You are short an option and want the obligation gone: buy to close.

Writing uncovered options is subject to margin requirements; see cash account vs margin account. For how a fast move can force short sellers to buy back at once, read about short covering. More guides are in trading concepts and in the options section.

Every pattern's results on one sheet

The only pattern cheat sheet with tested stats: 152 patterns, what the textbook says and what really happened on 6 markets. Free PDF, sent to your inbox.

The PDF by email, plus our newsletter: new tests and results that change. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.

Frequently asked questions

What does buy to open mean?

It opens a new long options position, or adds to one. You pay the premium and own the right to buy (call) or sell (put) the underlying at the strike price until expiration.

What does buy to close mean?

It closes a short options position, in full or in part. You buy back a contract you sold earlier, and the obligation that came with it ends.

What is the difference between sell to open and sell to close?

Sell to open creates a short position: you write the option and collect the premium. Sell to close exits a long position you already hold: you sell the option you bought.

Do I have to close an option before expiration?

No, but closing lets you take the gain or loss without going through exercise or assignment. If you are short, staying open into expiration keeps the assignment risk.

Can I buy to close for less than I sold?

Yes, and that is the writer's profit. Selling to open at 2.50 and buying to close at 1.00 leaves $150 per contract before fees, in a hypothetical example on a standard 100-share option.

Sources

  1. Options Industry Council, Options Overview for Investors (PDF)
  2. Options Industry Council, Open interest: why it matters
  3. Nasdaq, Opening and Closing Cross frequently asked questions (PDF)
  4. SEC, Release No. 34-91461, order approving Nasdaq's early opening imbalance indicator (PDF)
, Founder of PatternsWizard

Passionate about finance, quantitative trading and data analysis. Amaury built the PatternsWizard test bench, which detects each pattern on full price history and measures what happened next against random entries.

PatternsWizard tests chart and candlestick patterns on full market history, against random entries. How we test patterns.

179 patterns testedRandom-walk self-test passed

All trading concepts articles